Opinion: Greenman Requests Civility and Respectful Discourse after Garthwait Resignation
Feb26

Opinion: Greenman Requests Civility and Respectful Discourse after Garthwait Resignation

By Jessica Greenman, Columnist Seeing just how much has already been said on the matter, I almost did not write this piece.  The last thing I want to do is add more noise to our ever-louder world. However, I hope my fellow Gettysburgians will hear me out. I do not want to speak directly about the photograph in question.  Some people have been shocked and offended by it, some outraged that anyone would have such a reaction.  Many fall...

Read More
Opinion: Frigon ’18 Calls for Greater Dialog Concerning Garthwait Situation
Feb26

Opinion: Frigon ’18 Calls for Greater Dialog Concerning Garthwait Situation

By Luke Frigon, ’18 When I first read the news of the now-infamous “Hogan’s Heroes” photo, I was astounded. It shook me up to think that a friend I admire and trust as much as Mr. Garthwait could be associated with such seemingly-evil imagery. Reactions to the photo poured in, and we heard and read the words of a campus community struggling to grasp its own history and identity, and the choices that one of its most prominent...

Read More
Opinion: Buzzerd ’64 Provides Context on Hogan’s Heroes after Garthwait Resignation
Feb25

Opinion: Buzzerd ’64 Provides Context on Hogan’s Heroes after Garthwait Resignation

By Harry W. Buzzerd, Jr. ’64 A Sunday afternoon to a Tuesday afternoon ended a process by which President Riggs broadly notified the resignation of Mr. Garthwait from the Board of Trustees.  National media coverage quickly followed, creating smear to what is Gettysburg College, past and present. A decades loyal and generous Alum openly acknowledged that 38 years ago at a fraternity party he role-played the iconic WWII German...

Read More
Opinion: Himmelreich ’76 Asserts Nazism is not Supported in Garthwait Photo
Feb25

Opinion: Himmelreich ’76 Asserts Nazism is not Supported in Garthwait Photo

By Janet Knauff Himmelreich, ’76 I have not even read the Gettysburgian since I graduated in 1976.  However, I am appalled by what has happened in the past few days and feel I need to respond to the student, Cameron Sauers who “found” the yearbook photo from 1980 and decided to take it upon himself to cause a “teachable”  moment.  It would be most helpful to understand the circumstances that caused him to...

Read More
Opinion: Moderate Democrat Needed to Defeat Trump
Feb23

Opinion: Moderate Democrat Needed to Defeat Trump

By Steven Gibbs, Guest Columnist Between the longest government shutdown in history, the looming special council probe, and the faux-crisis at the border and subsequent executive overreach to acquire border wall funds, President Trump continues to dig a deeper grave for himself. By all outward appearances, the stars are perfectly aligned for a democratic president in 2020. Unfortunately, the Democrats are currently mired in their own...

Read More
A Note from the Editor: Reflections on the Last Few Days
Feb22

A Note from the Editor: Reflections on the Last Few Days

Among the most important lessons I learned my freshman year while participating in the Garthwait Leadership Center’s Leadership Certificate program was the importance of making regular time for reflection. As I reflect on what has transpired over the last four days, I see a situation that clearly transcends Bob Garthwait. In reading every one of the hundreds of comments posted across The Gettysburgian‘s digital platforms...

Read More